Brahma Sūtra 3.1.13

Śaṅkara

Advaita Vedānta

Sūtra

संयमने त्वनुभूयेतरेषामारोहावरोहौ तद्गतिदर्शनात्

saṃyamane tvanubhūyetareṣāmārohāvarohau tadgatidarśanāt

Sūtra translation

But of the others, after having enjoyed the fruits of their actions in Sa;«yamana, ascent and descent take place ; as such a course is declared (by scripture).

‘ But ’ discards the piirvapaksha. It is not true that all men go to the moon. For the ascent to the moon is

Read Śaṅkara’s commentary →

Rāmānuja

Viśiṣṭādvaita Vedānta

Sūtra

संयमने त्वनुभूयेतरेषामारोहावरोहौ तद्गनिदर्शनात्

saṃyamane tvanubhūyetareṣāmārohāvarohau tadganidarśanāt

Sūtra translation

But of the others having enjoyed in Samyamana, there is ascent and descent; as such a course is declared.

Of the others, i.e. those who do not perform sacrifices, and so on, there is ascent to the moon and descent from there, only

Read Rāmānuja’s commentary →

Madhva

Dvaita Vedānta

Numbered 3.1.14 in this text

Sūtra

संयमनेत्वनुभूयेतरेषामारोहावरोहौ तद्गतिदर्शनात्

saṃyamanetvanubhūyetareṣāmārohāvarohau tadgatidarśanāt

Sūtra translation

Further only after having fully undergone the punishment (of Yama) in hell, (some of these others) ascend .come into worldly existence), some descend into still nether re- gions. as seen from Scripture describing their various courses.

When they have undergone punishment dealt out by Varna in hell, some ascend, some descend (lower down) The particle 1 Tu * in the

Read Madhva’s commentary →