Brahma Sūtra 3.1.8

Śaṅkara

Advaita Vedānta

Sūtra

कृतात्ययेऽनुशयवान्दृष्टस्मृतिभ्यां यथेतमनेवं च

kṛtātyaye'nuśayavāndṛṣṭasmṛtibhyāṃ yathetamanevaṃ ca

Sūtra translation

On the passing away of the works (the soul redescends) with a remainder, according to scripture and Smmi, as it went (i.e. passing through the same stations) and not thus (i.e. in the inverse order).

Scripture states that the souls of those who perform sacrifices, and the like, rise on the road leading through smoke, and so on, to

Read Śaṅkara’s commentary →

Rāmānuja

Viśiṣṭādvaita Vedānta

Sūtra

कृतात्ययेनुशयवान्दृष्टस्मृतिभ्यां यथेतमनेवं च

kṛtātyayenuśayavāndṛṣṭasmṛtibhyāṃ yathetamanevaṃ ca

Sūtra translation

On the passing away of the works, with a remainder, according to Scripture and Smriti; as it went and not so.

The text declares that those who only perform sacrifices and useful works ascend by the road of the fathers, and again return to the

Read Rāmānuja’s commentary →

Madhva

Dvaita Vedānta

Madhva’s text divides this sūtra into two sūtras.

Numbered 3.1.8 in this text

Sūtra

कृतात्ययेऽनुशयवान् दृष्टस्मृतिभ्याम्

kṛtātyaye'nuśayavān dṛṣṭasmṛtibhyām

Sūtra translation

When (some of) the works are exhausted by fruition, he (the soul) comes down with a remainder (of works), as appears from Sruti and Smriti.

For the Sruti says : “ Then with a remainder he comes (back) to this world, again does work, again goes, again comes back

Read Madhva’s commentary on 3.1.8 →

Numbered 3.1.9 in this text

Sūtra

यथेतमनेवञ्च

yathetamanevañca

Sūtra translation

(The soul comes back) as it went; as well as by differ- ent (steps).

From the Kashayana Sruti, “ From Smoke he goes to Cloud, from Cloud to Ether, from Ether to the sphere of the Moon, and

Read Madhva’s commentary on 3.1.9 →