Brahma Sūtra 4.4.17

Śaṅkara

Advaita Vedānta

Sūtra

जगद्व्यापारवर्जं प्रकरणादसंनिहितत्वाच्च

jagadvyāpāravarjaṃ prakaraṇādasaṃnihitatvācca

Sūtra translation

With the exception of world-business (the released possess all lordly power), (the Lord) being the topic (when} world-business is refc^rred to), and (the souls) not being near (to such business).

The following doubt here presents itself. Do those who through meditations on the qualified Brahman enter, together with their manas, into a condition of

Read Śaṅkara’s commentary →

Rāmānuja

Viśiṣṭādvaita Vedānta

Sūtra

जगद्व्यापारवर्जं प्रकरणादसंनिहितत्वाच्च

jagadvyāpāravarjaṃ prakaraṇādasaṃnihitatvācca

Sūtra translation

With the exception of world-energy; on account of leading subject-matter and of non-proximity.

The doubt here presents itself whether the power of the released soul is a universal power such as belongs to the Supreme Person, extending

Read Rāmānuja’s commentary →

Madhva

Dvaita Vedānta

Madhva’s text divides this sūtra into two sūtras.

Numbered 4.4.17 in this text

Sūtra

जगद्व्यापारवर्जम्

jagadvyāpāravarjam

Sūtra translation

The released obtains all wishes except the power of (creating) the world, etc.

The text says: “ He has become immortal and attained all his wishes ” (A. A. II-5-4); still the text should be understood to

Read Madhva’s commentary on 4.4.17 →

Numbered 4.4.18 in this text

Sūtra

प्रकरणादसन्निहितत्वाच्च

prakaraṇādasannihitatvācca

Sūtra translation

And because diva (the sold) is the topic of the pass- age and is fan away front (such power).

For the passage deals with the individual soul and such powers are very far from his reach. This is said in the Vârâha: “

Read Madhva’s commentary on 4.4.18 →